Cabrini College
English & Communication Dept.
ENG 373 Homer's Iliad and Odyssey
Dr. Jerry Zurek
Summer 2007

Basic Information

Reading Schedule:

Week of May 20 

Tuesday: Read Iliad Bk 1&2, read web pages & do 2 discussions, 1 for each book
        ·  The Iliad - Book 01 - The Rage of Achilles
        ·  The Iliad - Book 02 - The Great Gathering of Armies
Wednesday: Read Bk 3&4, read web pages & do 2 discussions, 1 for each book
        ·  The Iliad - Book 03 - Helen's two husbands duel for her
        ·  The Iliad - Book 04 - The truce erupts in war
Thursday: Read Bk 6, read web pages & do 1 discussions, skip book 5
        ·  The Iliad - Book 05 - The 'aristeia' of Diomedes
        ·  The Iliad - Book 06 - Hector returns to Troy
Friday: Skip Bk 7&8
        ·  The Iliad - Book 07 - Ajax duels with Hector
        ·  The Iliad - Book 08 - The tide of battle turns
Friday: Read Bk 9, read web page & do 1 discussion
        ·  The Iliad - Book 09 - The embassy to Achilles
       

Week of May 27

Tuesday: Read Bk 10, read web page & do 1 discussion
        ·  The Iliad - Book 10 - Marauding through the night 
Wednesday: Read Bk 11&12, read web pages & do 2 discussions, 1 for each book
        ·  The Iliad - Book 11 - Agamemnon's finest hour
        ·  The Iliad - Book 12 - The Trojans storm the rampart
Thursday: Read Bk 15&16, read web pages & do 1 discussion for 16
        ·  You may skip: The Iliad Book 13 Battling for the ships
        ·  You may skip: The Iliad Book 14 Hera outflanks Zeus
        ·  The Iliad - Book 15 - The Achaean armies at bay
        ·  The Iliad - Book 16 - Patroclus fights and dies
Friday: paper 1--you may send it anytime over the weekend.

Week of June 3

Monday, May 31: Read Bk 17&18, read web pages & do 1 discussion, for Book 18
        ·  The Iliad - Book 17 - Menelaus' Finest Hour - The fight for Patroclus's body
        ·  The Iliad - Book 18 - The shield of Achilles
Tuesday, June 1: Read Bk 19&21, read web pages & do 1 discussion
        ·  The Iliad - Book 19 - The champion arms for battle
        ·  You may skip: The Iliad - Book 20 - The Olympian gods in arms
        ·  The Iliad - Book 21 - Achilles fights the river
Wednesday, June 2: Read Bk 22&24, read web pages & do 2 discussions, 1 for each book
        ·  The Iliad - Book 22 - The death of Hector
        ·  The Iliad - Book 24
Friday: Paper 2--you may send it anytime over the weekend.

Week of June 10

Monday: Read Bernard Knox's Intro and Bk 1; read my web pages and do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 01 - Athena inspires Telemachus
Tuesday: Read 02 and 03: read my web pages & do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 02 - Telemachus confronts the suitors
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 03 - Other homecomings; Telemachus visits King Nestor in Pylos
Wednesday: Read Bk 4(698-954) and 5; read my web pages & do 1 discussion. 
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 04 - Telemachus visits Menelaus in Sparta
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 05 - Castaway
Thursday: Read Bk 06 and 07: read my web pages & do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 06 - Nausicaa and the Phaeacians
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 07 - Odysseus' wish is granted by King Alcinous
Friday: Read Bk 8 (1-289, 545-657) & 9; read my web pages and do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 08 - The Mystery Builds - Who is the Stranger?
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 09 - Odysseus recounts his odyssey: The Cyclops

Week of June 17

Monday: Read Bk 10 and 11, read web pages & do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 10 - Odysseus recounts his odyssey: Circe
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 11 - Odysseus recounts his odyssey: The Dead
Tuesday: Read Bk 12 and 13, read web pages & do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 12 - Odysseus recounts his odyssey: Three Perils
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 13 - Ithaca at Last
Wednesday: Read Bk 14 and 15, read web pages & do 1 discussion.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 14 - Odysseus and the Loyal Swineherd, Eumaeus
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 15 - Telemachus comes home
Thursday: Read Bk 16 & 17, read web pages & do 1 discussion for 16 or 17.
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 16 - Father and Son
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 17 - Stranger at the Gate
Friday: Read Bk 18 & 19, read web pages & do 1 discussion for each book.
       ·  The Odyssey - Book 18 - The Beggar-King of Ithaca
       ·  The Odyssey - Book 19 - Penelope and Odysseus speak, finally

Week of June 24

Monday: Read Bk 20 & 21, read web pages & do 1 discussion for 21
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 20 - Portents Gather
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 21 - Odysseus strings his bow
Tuesday: Read Bk 22 & 23, read web pages & do 1 discussion for 23
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 22 - Slaughter
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 23 - Penelope
Wednesday: Read Bk 24, read web pages and do discussion for 24
        ·  The Odyssey - Book 24 - Peace

Due June 30: Paper 3.  


Introduction & Course Goals:

Imagine traveling back in time almost 3,000 years and seeing what life was like then with almost photographic reality. Imagine getting inside the mind and imagination of a writer who lived 2,750 years ago and seeing the world through his eyes and finding out what seems to be permanent in human nature and what is merely the way we happen to do something now. That is what I find amazing about reading the Iliad and the Odyssey, that something so ancient speaks to me so clearly and directly today. Therefore, one of the course goals is to understand two works of literature that have formed the basis of Western culture.

The Iliad especially will at first strike you as strange and foreign. Harold Bloom, a great contemporary literary critic, ascribes this strangeness to two ways in which the world of the Iliad is different from our world: the Greek gods and the role of Greek fate is so different from our conception of fate and God in the Hebrew-Christian tradition. But while the cosmology of the Greek Olympian gods is so foreign to many of us Westerners personally, the comparisons and contrasts to the cosmology and theology we have grown up with provide invigorating opportunities for reflection. Therefore, a study of the Iliad will sharpen your sense of how ways of understanding humanity, society, and divinity have evolved over time.

The Odyssey is more accessable, more readable, especially if you have had no background in Greek literature, mythology, or epics. The Odyssey is a darn good story and has a lot of variety--killing, funny episodes, sex, drugs, love, tenderness--you name it, The Odyssey's got it. The Iliad is more sublime--the emotions are higher, deeper, stronger, and therefore less ordinary. The challenges Odysseus faces, while sometimes set in a fabulous setting, are more the challenges of everyday life. The author of The Odyssey (assuming that a different poet wrote The Odyssey) was inspired by The Iliad and defined his work in contrast with it. As a result of reading the Odyssey, you will understand more clearly the basis of much of literature. Therefore, a brief statement of our course goals are these:

  • to understand the meaning of The Iliad and The Odyssey of Homer as epic poems and works of literature.
  • to understand the context of Homer's time as it relates to understanding the epics and how these epics have influenced our Western society.
  • to determine your own interpretation of the epics after having compared and contrasted the interpretations of various critics and students.

Course Requirements (syllabus is subject to change)
Online written journals and discussions using WebCT. (50 percent)
Three papers (15 percent, 15 percent, 20 percent)

Journals and online discussions:

The online discussions are meant to take the place of class discussion. Therefore, you are expected to take part in extensive discussions of each item on the syllabus. The discussions are not meant to be like traditional journals in which a person writes privately about each book. Rather, for online discussions to be successful, each participant must make substantive contributions on each book (points you initiate), read the discussions of the other participants, and comment on those postings (your response to some others). I make suggestions for discussion on the web site or you can post your own reflection. It is most important that you keep up with the schedule. Full credit will be given only for timely postings. Seven to ten sentences would we expected for each discussion that you initiate. Responses to other people's postings may be of any length.


Papers:

Your papers should explore the meaning of The Iliad and The Odyssey for you. In some cases, the characters and themes will challenge what you hold, in other cases, support and inspire. You should always thoroughly analyze the poems in order to support and substantiate your points. Each paper should be at least 5 pages long.

Try to set aside chunks of undistracted time for your reading. Make brief notes in your book for each logical section. Sections may be as short as part of a column. Just brief notes recalling what is going on may be helpful.

Getting started on your papers: Review all your notes and responses to your reading. Discuss your ideas with others. Do you find a nagging question, some one idea that is really important to you? Are there any patterns of issues or questions? Writing on these topics is usually most interesting.

Review the appropriate web sites and my Powerpoint presentations.

A thesis that makes connections between two works or among several works is usually more interesting than a thesis that focuses on only one item, but again I leave that judgment to you. Your thesis should be your own view on an interesting topic. A good thesis should make a strong point, not state something that is factual or obvious. See this site for examples. You may develop a topic explored in a discussion thread, if you wish, or you may embark on an entirely new topic. I have some sample thesis statements for you from actual student papers, with my comments and how to improve the thesis. I am providing some sample papers from students in previous years. Each paper got an A grade. Sample Comparison Paper 1 .

Think about who is reading your paper. It is someone who shares some basic knowledge with you. Assume that the reader has read the books. Therefore, don't summarize the plot. You don't have to say, "Homer, the Greek epic poet, wrote The Iliad." You can, however, situate your point within the context of the poem. Refer your points to the poem as much as possible. Therefore, don't make purely personal judgments like "I think Odysseus's son is a jerk." Make reference to the exact words of the epic, but long stretches of quotes without your own interwoven thought is tedious. Long quotes should not count as part of your 6 pages for a paper. Avoid plopping quotes in without graceful introduction.

You may consult and cite other critics if you wish, but if you use other critics, it should be to provide a starting point or point of contrast to your own. There is no doubt that resources in a college library are far richer than what you will find online. If you are familiar with writing essays for other literature courses, there is nothing you need to do differently here. If you have never had a college literature course, please let me know if you would like more guidance.

Academic honesty is important. This course follows the college's Academic Honesty policy in the student handbook.Footnotes to the epics are not needed. Just identify references with these abbreviations ( Il. 12. 22-43). If you refer to other critics or online sources, you must acknowledge their ideas, using MLA format.

I upload all student papers to TurnItIn.com, a website that checks papers for plagiarism.

You will find all the writing and citing guidance that you need for your papers at the college's Writing Center web site http://www.cabrini.edu/writing/tools/index.htm


What each grade means:
Need Help with WebCT? Always check the Help Menu in WebCT. This is the person to contact for assistance:

Chris Shields: chris.shields@cabrini.edu

WebCT instructions for email and papers:

  • You must write your papers in Microsoft Word. The college library will provide you with a free disk of Word to install on your computer, if you don't have word.
  • How to send your papers to me: (Click here to get these instructions in printable form)
    • When you save, please save it like this: Smith373IliadPaper1.doc (No spaces!)
    • WebCT will not recognize file names with spaces or characters that are not numbers or letters.
  • Then submit your assignment through WebCT (instructions)
  • Email: I recommend you set up your WebCT email for the course so that important emails go directly to your regular email account. Therefore, when you send me a paper, for example, you will be notified by email that I received it. To set up your email, click on Mail and then on Manage Messages. Then click on Forward My Email to: ________. Fill in your email address here and click the radio button and click Go.

    Cabrini College Academic Honesty Policy

    The principal objective of the Cabrini College Academic Honesty Policy is to encourage a dynamic, open and honest intellectual climate based on the personal and academic integrity of all members. It is the responsibility of students to help maintain the community of academic integrity. Students shall not receive credit for work that is not a product of their own efforts. For a full description of the policy, please see pages 48-52 of the 2003-2004 Undergraduate Catalog.
    Academic dishonesty includes, but is not limited to:

    • Plagiarism
    • Cheating
    • Information falsification or fabrication
    • Theft or destruction of intellectual property
    • Facilitation of academic dishonesty

    For a first violation, the faculty member will meet with the student or otherwise communicate the charge. The faculty member will complete an Academic Honesty Violation Charge Form, stating the violation and assigning a penalty. The student should sign and date the charge form and return it to the faculty member. The student may request a hearing before the Academic Honesty Board by indicating that option on the form. For a second violation in a given course, the faculty member will follow the same procedures as in the first incident but will assign a penalty of failure of the course without privilege of withdrawal. For any second or subsequent violation during a studentÕs academic career at Cabrini College the Academic Honesty Board shall conduct a hearing.

    Disability Support Services

    Cabrini College provides support services and appropriate accommodations for qualified students with documented disabilities. If you are a student who requires classroom or testing accommodations, please contact Disability Support Services in the Rooymans Center, room 4, 610-902-8572 or email at dss@cabrini.edu. Please note that classroom or testing accommodations can only be provided to students who have Accommodation Notification Forms from Disability Support Services. Students are responsible for providing the instructor with the Accommodation Notification Forms and informing the instructor when they need academic adjustments.


For problems or questions regarding this web contact jzurek@cabrini.edu.